A friend asks if there has been a solid refutation of Pat Buchanan’s book. I’m sure there has been, and I wouldn’t be surprised if it has been published in Finest Hour, but could you give me the citation? —W.M.
Professor David Freeman at Cal State Fullerton wrote the full review in Finest Hour 139, Summer 2008. I ganged up on poor Pat by writing about his selective quotation techniques in my accompanying editorial, which I reprise below.
Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War: How Britain Lost Its Empire and the West Lost the World, by Patrick J. Buchanan. New York, Crown, 518 pp., $29.95.
A problem illustrated by Pat Buchanan’s book is the rampant use of selective quotes. No animus toward the author: I have respect for Pat Buchanan and even voted for him in the 1992 New Hampshire Primary (the beginning of the end for King George I). “I like a man who grins when he fights,” as Churchill said. But selective quotations edited to distort the facts and to fit a predetermined mindset are out of bounds.
To establish Churchill’s “lust” for World War I, for example, Buchanan quotes him on 28 July 1914: “Everything tends towards catastrophe & collapse. I am interested, geared up and happy. Is it not horrible to be built like that?…” (page 28)
But he omits the rest of that passage: “…The preparations have a hideous fascination for me. I pray to God to forgive me for such fearful moods of levity. Yet I w[oul]d do my best for peace, and nothing w[oul]d induce me wrongfully to strike the blow.” (from Martin Gilbert, editor, Winston S. Churchill, Companion Volume II, Part 3, page 1989, back in print at Hillsdale College Press.)
As the war mounts on 10 January 1915, Buchanan has Churchill exclaiming: “My God! This, this is living History. Everything we are doing and saying is thrilling—it will be read by a thousand generations, think of that! Why I would not be out of this glorious delicious war for anything the world could give me (eyes glowing but with a slight anxiety lest the word ‘delicious’ should jar on me).” (page 66)
The latter is pure hearsay from the notoriously waspish Margot Asquith—but assume he said it. To suit his thesis, Pat trims the rest of what Margot reported: “…I say don’t repeat that I said the word ‘delicious’—you know what I mean…..” (Winston S. Churchill, Companion Volume III, Part 1, page 400.)
Possessed of the words deleted from Buchanan’s quote of Margot’s idle chit-chat, one might ask what Churchill meant by “you know what I mean”? Did he assume Margot knew he realized what barbarity war was—that he had been warning of the apocalyptic nature of a European war since 1903?
I searched in vain among Pat’s collection of lusty war quotes for contrary expressions—and there are many. Take Churchill’s 1909 remark after watching German Army maneuvers: “Much as war attracts me & fascinates my mind with its tremendous situations—I feel more deeply every year—& can measure the feeling here in the midst of arms—what vile & wicked folly & barbarism it all is” (Winston S. Churchill, Companion Volume II, Part 2, 912).
Buchanan does include an early 1900s remark about the dangers of a European war, but only to imply that Churchill had changed his tune by 1914. Nowhere do we read exculpatory evidence, such as Churchill’s 1911 proposal for an Anglo-German “naval holiday” or his plea, at the eleventh hour, for a peace conference attended by all the Heads of State of Europe.
Then there is Hitler, on whom Pat has been industrious. Under Hitler’s photo we read: “‘If our country were defeated, I hope we should find a champion as indomitable to restore our courage and lead us back to our place among the nations.’ —Churchill on Hitler, 1937.”
This sentence has often been culled out to be misunderstood by the unwary. Here is the full passage (Churchill, Step by Step, 1947 edition, 158). Draw your own conclusions:
To feel deep concern about the armed power of Germany is in no way derogatory to Germany. On the contrary, it is a tribute to the wonderful and terrible strength which Germany exerted in the Great War, when almost single-handed she fought nearly all the world and nearly beat them. Naturally, when a people who have shown such magnificent military qualities are arming night and day, its neighbours, who bear the scars of previous conflicts, must be anxious and ought to be vigilant. One may dislike Hitler’s system and yet admire his patriotic achievement. If our country were defeated I hope we should find a champion as indomitable to restore our courage and lead us back to our place among the nations. I have on more than one occasion made my appeal in public that the Führer of Germany should now become the Hitler of peace.
All of which shows yet again that you can use Churchill’s words, vacuumed like a gigantic Hoover and offered without ellipses by the faithful Martin Gilbert, to prove anything. You only have to pre-select and edit the right ones.